Visit YaddaYadda's column >>

YADDAYADDA

Add To Watchlist
Articles Posted: 4; Links Seeded: 5
Member Since: 11/2008Last Seen: 11/27/2009

An Interesting Conversation With A German

advertisement

He considers himself an American now. A very proud American, who has lived in the United States for 20 years. I made his acquaintance while looking for a replacement vehicle after having crashed mine into a building (another story altogether). You see, it was his vehicle I was purchasing. It was a 1995 Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo that had a little problem with a rear main seal. I will tell you that I paid $1000 for the Jeep, and $642 for the repairs. Because I trust implicitly those who repaired my vehicle, I got a helluva deal. Anyhow, while I was waiting for AAA to tow the Jeep away, Jens invited me to sit on his deck and have coffee with him. It was a fantastic fall day, so I accepted.

Somehow we got on the subject of diversity. Because Jens and I are of an age, I was wary of this discussion and I could sense his disquiet as well. But we forged on, because I was as curious to learn his point of view as I believe he was to learn mine.

I found it interesting that our points of view - his, a naturalized American and mine, American born - are identical.

Jens believes that this country, the United States of America, is truly the best country in the world to live in. He believes it is the best country to thrive in, to build a business in, to raise a family in, and to realize your dream in. It is why he moved here and is why he still lives here and is raising his family here. He LOVES this country. He would live nowhere else but here.

Jens also believes that diversity breeds dissent, hatred, separation, and entitlement. He does not believe in the "hyphenated American". He thinks the "hyphenated American" is what separates us. It does not bring us together as Americans. It, happily, shoves in our collective faces, the things that make us different from each other. It says to us, "Look! Here are the things that separate us one from the other!", and "See what you have done to us! Pay us what you owe!"

He told me, "When people talk to me about diversity, I say, 'My mind will be open if yours will be'."

  • 2 Votes
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.

Back To Top

Published to:

What's this?
Who's leading the conversation?
This visualization below allows you to see the impact that each user has on the current conversation. The top row contains the group of users who have had the most impact, the 2nd row the group of users who have had the 2nd most impact (et cetera). Users with similar impact are grouped together, and the average score of the group is shown to the left of the group. The author of the article is also shown on the left, in their corresponding group. Each user's score is based on the number of comments the user has made plus the number of votes their comments have received. The scores are calculated relative one another, so while their absolute value is not particularly important, their relative difference does indicate a larger difference in impact on the conversation.
7.7
2.9
{"commentId":10554016,"authorDomain":"deepdixie"}

Jens believes that this country, the United States of America, is truly the best country in the world to live in. He believes it is the best country to thrive in, to build a business in, to raise a family in, and to realize your dream in. It is why he moved here and is why he still lives here and is raising his family here. He LOVES this country. He would live nowhere else but here.

Jens also believes that diversity breeds dissent, hatred, separation, and entitlement. He does not believe in the "hyphenated American". He thinks the "hyphenated American" is what separates us. It does not bring us together as Americans.

Nice post. :) Also a little bit eerie for me, since this man not only shares my Danish paternal grandfather's path to America and his views, but also his first name. That logic isn't a new concept, either, since Grandpa died years ago, and came to the USA long before I was born.

Respect for all of the different cultures that have come together here, and have helped to make us the unique country we are is great. From that standpoint, I respect and enjoy diversity, since I like an interesting environment as opposed to a bland one.

When differences are used to keep others at arm's length, or used as a way to exact "guilt" from those who had absolutely no part of the original issue, I have to disengage from it. There are many people here in the USA who had ancestors arrive under some of the worst possible circumstances; all colors, all nationalities/cultures.

We're here now, and it's time to move forward, not live in the past.

{"commentId":10554016,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"deepdixie"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#1 - Sun Nov 8, 2009 1:55 AM EST
{"commentId":10567569,"authorDomain":"monsterskin63"}
We're here now, and it's time to move forward, not live in the past

Exactly! One thing I got from him during the beginning of our conversation is I think he was a little bit nervous about sharing his ideas with me. I got the impression that maybe he thought somehow his viewpoint might be compared to that of the Nazis because he was German. Maybe he's had to deal with that in the past, I don't know. I let him know without coming right out and saying it that he wouldn't be judged by me because of his nationality. We had a great conversation, and he was really adamant about the point of "You're either an American or you're not. You can't just go halfway."

I think that diversity is a double-edged sword. On one hand it can be used as an educational tool to show that we're all different and those differences should be celebrated. We can learn from each other if we're open minded enough. The flip-side is when it's used for either forced or self segregation and pointing out how "ignorant" the "other guy" is.

Thanks for commenting! :~)

{"commentId":10567569,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"monsterskin63"}
  • 2 votes
#1.1 - Sun Nov 8, 2009 10:53 PM EST
{"commentId":10568372,"authorDomain":"deepdixie"}
I got the impression that maybe he thought somehow his viewpoint might be compared to that of the Nazis because he was German.

Which is really a shame if he's experienced that with others, especially considering how long ago WWII ended.

After typing that, I guess I should probably qualify that statement by saying it certainly isn't making light of the horrors of the Nazi regime in any way. Just that one can never assume certain things based on where another comes from. Not only did none of us ask to be born, none asked to be born in any particular place, or with any particular outer appearance.

Yes, it takes an open mind on both sides of the dialogue, for sure. One doesn't have to be of any particular background to have had certain "experiences". Dealing with #@$*!#@s happens, no matter who you are or where you're from. I'm not making light of them at all, of course. But building up a figurative wall doesn't help, it only makes things worse.

I believe how one deals with it/them, and how much one truly wants things to change for the better, is what determines your quality of life. [For want of a better term.]

{"commentId":10568372,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"deepdixie"}
  • 1 vote
#1.2 - Mon Nov 9, 2009 12:12 AM EST
{"commentId":10569311,"authorDomain":"monsterskin63"}
Which is really a shame if he's experienced that with others, especially considering how long ago WWII ended.

I know. But how often does someone just toss out that "Nazi card"? These days it's quite often when folks engage in political conversation.

For some strange reason, I was (and still am) obsessed with WWII history from the viewpoint of the Jews and other oppressed minorities of that time. I don't know why, but I've always felt drawn to that time period. I remember in Jr. & Sr. high school, checking out every book in our town library on the subject. I'm sure the librarians thought I was a nut case! LOL. I have lots of books in my bookcases here at home on that subject. I just devour anything I can get my hands on about it. Sometimes I dream about it. It's damned freaky.

The thing that gets me is that people have no idea the horrors that Nazism brought to the world, unless they care to truly educate themselves. So when they glibly toss out the words "Nazi" or "Hitler", it just burns me up. I think Jens...and I could just see it in his face...has heard that word bandied about and was really wary about whether or not he would hear it come out of my mouth. I could literally see him relax his posture as we got further into our conversation.

I'm really glad I got the chance to talk to him. It was nice to see the perspective of someone who chose to be an American and understand why he made that choice. It made me proud of my country. Go Jens! :~)

And it's intersting that your grandfather has the same first name!

{"commentId":10569311,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"monsterskin63"}
  • 2 votes
#1.3 - Mon Nov 9, 2009 2:40 AM EST
{"commentId":10569590,"authorDomain":"deepdixie"}

Yadda, people toss out a lot of "cards" these days, and seem to completely disregard the true meaning of a lot of the words used; if they even know what they mean to begin with. And they're used all too often.

I'm a huge devotee of history myself, going all the way back to ancient ages and civilizations. I've always been one of those "inward" people, I guess. I'm sure as heck not patting myself on the back or insinuating I'm perfect in any way, because I'm not at all! [I have a pretty wicked temper, for one thing. I try to control it. But sometimes...]

The closest I can come to describing it is a deep compassion, even for total strangers I have never met, just read or hear about. It can be a curse at times, especially when I was much younger, and would become very frustrated over not being able to control things, or "fix" the world.

Everything from natural catastrophes down through time, to slavery [African and otherwise] to the utter horror of the Holocaust, to things going on all over the world, present day; they keep me up at night, thinking of the humans involved.

How some people can be so careless to make casual comparisons to those who have done truly evil things is beyond me. I suspect all too many of them don't really know why they do; it sounds dramatic, perhaps. They have no idea of the damage it does, or they don't care. The goal is to keep their little walls intact, or maybe it's to simply shut down an opposing point of view with an attempt at "shock and guilt". Hard telling, but it burns me up, too.

I was born at the tail end of the "baby boom" period, to older parents who had married a bit later than most of their peers to begin with. I came along almost a decade after my two older siblings. My parents were from opposite areas of the country [mother from upstate NY, father from LA, with a Danish father and a mother from an old southern family] and I grew up not only feeling as though I had one foot in two different generations, but one in two different worlds.

Long, long story, much too long to even try to condense here. My paternal grandfather was actually old enough to almost have been my great-grandfather, but he probably had the most appreciative approach of all of them. Even at the advanced age he was by the time I knew him, he was so balanced and logical. He didn't come here because of dissatisfaction with his home country; it was more of an opportunity issue. He was an engineer, with an engineer's mind, and his family owned dairy farms.

It was good for me as a young girl to see that in him; that ability to adapt, and to see the positive. I only wish I'd been able to know him longer. By contrast, there were also members of my mother's family who left an indelible mark on her attitudes. Her paternal grandparents were second-generation Germans, their views were a bit different from Jens'. [As in, night and day.] I kid you not: My mother refused to buy a certain boxed pancake mix because the ingredients listed on the box included vanilla. Her grandmother told her that [paraphrased quote] "Jewish people cooked with vanilla, therefore she would not".

Granted, that quote was made back when my mother was still in high school, which would have been the early 1940s. [Not that it makes the remark any more palatable, of course.] But it just boggles my mind today if I think of it. But I can't fault all Germans for that, nor will I hang my head in shame over the fact that this lady was my great-grandmother. I never even met her.

That is why I believe what we as a society pass on to our children is so very important, as well as what we as adults from different backgrounds can learn from each other if we just speak honestly. And by that, I believe the focus should be on the similarities we all share, not the differences.

It is interesting that this man you met has the same name as my grandfather and father. Jens is the Scandinavian version of the name John. The Germanic version is often Johann, or another variant, but like so many names, this man might have either been named after a relative, or perhaps his parents simply liked the name.

My poor father. Having the name "Jens", especially coupled with the 9-letter surname that came after it, was a little odd for a young boy growing up in Louisiana all those years ago. ;) He shortened it to "Jay" as an adult. My maiden surname never failed to cause a raised eyebrow or two when I was growing up, that's for sure. I was still proud of it, but I would never have considered hyphenating anything.

I'm really glad you met your Jens, and commented on it here. And I'd bet he's glad he met you, also.

{"commentId":10569590,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"deepdixie"}
    #1.4 - Mon Nov 9, 2009 4:22 AM EST
    {"commentId":10569626,"authorDomain":"monsterskin63"}

    Huh...that 9-letter last name wouldn't have happened to have started with a Q would it have? LOL! I swear, if you tell me it starts with a Q, I will pass out right here... *clunk*.

    Her paternal grandparents were second-generation Germans, their views were a bit different from Jens'. [As in, night and day.] I kid you not: My mother refused to buy a certain boxed pancake mix because the ingredients listed on the box included vanilla. Her grandmother told her that [paraphrased quote] "Jewish people cooked with vanilla, therefore she would not".

    How funny is that? One of my very best friends in high school was a 2nd generation American of German heritage. The TV movie "The Holocaust" made it's debut when Oma was visiting from Germany and while they were watching the show, she told my friend Mary, "Don't you believe that. It's all a lie! Nothing but propaganda!" I mean, according to Mary, she was really angry that this mini-series had even been made.

    When she told me that we sort of looked at each other like... WTF?! We literally could NOT believe that there were actually people on the planet...GERMANS...who were denying the Holocaust! I asked Mary, "Well what did you say to her?" I mean, because we both knew the truth of it. And she just said, "Nothing. She's old and she's set in her ways. But I really worry about her soul."

    So I have to ask...did your Jens have folks trying to say.... Jens with a juh...or Jens with a Yuh? LOL!

    {"commentId":10569626,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"monsterskin63"}
    • 1 vote
    #1.5 - Mon Nov 9, 2009 4:44 AM EST
    {"commentId":10569659,"authorDomain":"deepdixie"}

    Nope, no Q. :) [Thought we'd have to cue twilight Zone music for a second there, tee hee.] It begins with an A, and there are only about 5 of us listed in the USA with that particular surname. Two are Swedish, the rest are direct descendants of Jens, Sr.; they're my cousins. It's an easy one to pronounce phonetically, but man... the trouble people had with it even when I was growing up, was amazing.

    And he was a "Yens" Jens. For some reason, in the old South a lot of people went by first and middle initials instead of a first name. [I will note it makes genealogy research pretty difficult at times; so many first and middle initials, so many different people. I even see it on old tombstones.]

    So my father was known as "J.E.", when he was growing up. That's why he shortened it to "Jay". When he was hospitalized in the early 80s shortly before he died, I noticed they actually has his little wrist band spelled "Jeans". [Which isn't all that surprising in New Orleans, given the French influence/spellings there.] I think that was one of the other reasons he used Jay; it was just easier.

    I remember when I first began to study the Holocaust in school. I would want to discuss things with my mother [who was a product of her time, and not a mean person, just... narrow, and quite repressed] and I would get stonewalled. She just didn't want to talk about it. My father was a veteran of WWII [and also Korea] and I was reluctant to bring up the subject to him for other reasons. Combat reasons; the more they see, the less they talk about in general, especially to their young daughters, so I respected that. I will say that his take on it was different from that of my mother's family.

    So I can believe this lady you speak of, and the denial. There really isn't anything one can say to someone who just refuses to accept documented truth. It does seem amazing, but I suspect it's a coping mechanism for some. Not that it makes you feel more comfortable around them, of course.

    {"commentId":10569659,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"deepdixie"}
      #1.6 - Mon Nov 9, 2009 5:12 AM EST
      Reply
      {"commentId":10569342,"authorDomain":"bhatgirl"}

      YaddaYadda: Reading about your conversation with Jens was like reading something my husband who is also a naturalized US citizen (born and raised in India) would say about this country.

      Even before he became a citizen he held these same opinions.

      I always tell him he was an American years before he became a citizen.

      As for being German and being associated with Nazis during WWII my grandfather was fired from Dow Chemical simply because of his name (very German).

      My grandfather was born and raised in this country. His family had been in the US for generations.

      It doesn't even reach the level of wrongness done to Americans of Japanese descent at the same time, but it did seriously impact his ability to care for his family.

      {"commentId":10569342,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"bhatgirl"}
      • 1 vote
      Reply#2 - Mon Nov 9, 2009 2:49 AM EST
      {"commentId":10569467,"authorDomain":"monsterskin63"}

      Desertgirl, wow! Honestly, I've never heard of Americans with German last names being persecuted! That is totally new to me but I'm not sure why I'm so surprised by it. I wonder why we've not heard more about that? I'm sure what happened to your grandfather wasn't in any way an anomaly. I'm sure things like that happened across the country.

      {"commentId":10569467,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"monsterskin63"}
        #2.1 - Mon Nov 9, 2009 3:22 AM EST
        {"commentId":10579920,"authorDomain":"kazutam"}

        Yadda

        I've never heard of Americans with German last names being persecuted!

        My mother had a German maiden name and grew up during that time(WWII), yes it happened and most folks don't talk about it. It was surprising to me to find this out especially after I had learned that my grandfather on that side died early due to wounds he suffered FIGHTING the Germans during WWI on the U.S. side.

        For her(my mother) at least it wasn't too bad because she was just a teen during those years, so it was mostly just nasty remarks.

        {"commentId":10579920,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"kazutam"}
          #2.2 - Mon Nov 9, 2009 4:10 PM EST
          Reply
          {"commentId":10629354,"authorDomain":"gonzo08383"}
          Jens also believes that diversity breeds dissent, hatred, separation, and entitlement. He does not believe in the "hyphenated American".

          i agree totally. the only problem i see is that whenever i say things like "in todays day and age do we really need the naacp?" or "if they can have black entertainment television then why cant i have whitey tv?" people are quick to call me racist. segregating a tv station just for blacks and an organization to advance "colored people" seems a lil racist to me. werent the 50's-60's all about de-segregation? why then are we still doing it? seems that its doing more harm than good in the mind of "outsiders" such as myself. i dont believe in african american because most: 1.have never been to africa, 2. cant list the countries that compose the continent, 3. know no or little history of the continent, and 4. know nothing of their ancestry. i would never call myself an Italian-American because i am not from Italy, my great grandparents were. I dont know Italian history or how to make authentic Lasagna. I'm a regular melting pot American, and damn proud of it.

          {"commentId":10629354,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"gonzo08383"}
            Reply#3 - Wed Nov 11, 2009 9:51 PM EST
            {"commentId":10637117,"authorDomain":"monsterskin63"}
            i dont believe in african american because most: 1.have never been to africa,

            I know, right? Man, Charlize Theron caught tons of crap for calling herself an African American on...I think it may have been SNL. And she's from freaking South Africa!

            {"commentId":10637117,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"monsterskin63"}
            • 1 vote
            #3.1 - Thu Nov 12, 2009 10:58 AM EST
            {"commentId":10640840,"authorDomain":"kazutam"}
            seems that its doing more harm than good in the mind of "outsiders" such as myself.

            Well the "standard" response I get when asking about that is "You're white you will NEVER understand".

            {"commentId":10640840,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"kazutam"}
            • 2 votes
            #3.2 - Thu Nov 12, 2009 1:32 PM EST
            {"commentId":10648034,"authorDomain":"gonzo08383"}

            yeah but white to me is the english. i'm of italian decent and way too proud of that heritage to consider myself white.

            {"commentId":10648034,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"gonzo08383"}
              #3.3 - Thu Nov 12, 2009 7:02 PM EST
              {"commentId":10649732,"authorDomain":"monsterskin63"}

              Yeah, gonzo....I hear you. You know what you REALLY are now, don't you??? You're a....a.....

              EURO-AMERICAN!!!! That's the catch-word now that covers everybody...it's the "new white".

              {"commentId":10649732,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"monsterskin63"}
              • 1 vote
              #3.4 - Thu Nov 12, 2009 8:41 PM EST
              {"commentId":10684789,"authorDomain":"gonzo08383"}

              and its still disgusts me. i'm not even a fan of bright colors. black, grey,blue, khaki, and denim. thats about all i care for unless its on a sports car then yellow or red will suffice.

              {"commentId":10684789,"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377","authorDomain":"gonzo08383"}
                #3.5 - Sun Nov 15, 2009 12:10 AM EST
                Reply
                {"canLink":false,"threadId":"719415","isPrivate":false}
                Leave a Comment:
                You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
                {"threadId":"719415","contentId":"3473377"}
                Start TrackingStart Tracking
                Stop TrackingStop Tracking